Final Thoughts on Giants Preseason 

Written by: Peter Scott Furman

I waited to comment on the last preseason game (Giants-Pats) until today when the squads were cut down to the 53-man limit. The game was a thriller. Blue won with the clock expiring as their 22-year-old placekicker capped off a perfect preseason with a 48-yarder to win the game.

Continue reading


Giants beat lowly Jets 32-31

In the most important preseason game of the year, the Giants took care of business against the pathetic Jets. Big Blue overwhelmed the Jets, taking a 29-3 lead at the half. Although the final score was a one-point win for the Giants, the major takeaway is the Giants defense. It is going to be a force this upcoming season. One of the components is Landon Collins.

Continue reading

The Book of Eli-Last Chapters.

The pinnacle of Eli Manning’s career was the magical 2011 season.  The Giants won a Super Bowl because of the superb play by Eli Manning.  His regular season stat line:

Att Comp Yards Cp % Td Int y/a yds/gm sacks qbr 4cb gwd
589 359 4933 61 29 16 8.4 308.3 28 67.1 7 8

Since this 2011 season, Eli has not matched or eclipsed these statistics.  Hands down, this was his best season as a professional.  What has happened since 2011?

Continue reading

Sifting through the Noise- My Thoughts on Giants Draft

Written by: Motown Blue

Some takeaways: The team appears to be frustrated with Eli, and the pick of Webb is about the future. The fact they tried to to trade up for Mahomes further confirms the likely truth behind that. If they had been able to coordinate that trade, it would have set them back by at least five years. I question McAdoo as it appears he seems arrogant about his evaluation of QBs to the point that they tried to trade up for him.

Apparently, they place their own players on the board as a measurement of whether to draft someone. They didn’t see the value of the OL that was on the board versus their own players. I am sorry, but they obviously need to re-think their evaluation of OL, considering how crappy they have been for the last two-plus years.

The Giants still have glaring holes on the roster outside of the obvious with OL. They struggled to cover a TE and the middle of the field. Who on their roster will do that? The LBs are very average, to be polite. We saw what happened when DRC went down versus GB. They lost Sensabaugh, Wade and Hall. Where is the CB depth? Tomlinson has an injury track record. Are they comfortable he will make it through a 16+ game schedule? They have one legitimate blocking TE on the roster. What happens if Ellison goes down?

There is still time between now and September to improve the roster, especially in the trenches, but it gets a lot harder now. The players that get cut are cut for a reason. The play of OL in the NFL has deteriorated in the last five years. Most teams will hold on to players that can actually block. Overall, I don’t see much improvement outside of some new toys on O but again, if your QB is too busy avoiding getting killed, then they are useless. Your hope is that Solari pulls off the greatest coaching year of his career.

Initial Thoughts on Draft

Written by: Peter Furman

Let me start off with the Wayne Gallman pick.

Here is the problem: the fact this man was chosen here is questionable. He played for Clemson-the National Champions-and the runner up last year. In fact, Clemson had a very mediocre-to-poor running game and could easily have lost five to six more times as they won these games by less than a touchdown. The state of the game today as compared to before is there used to be a half dozen or more great teams and many more truly exceptional athletes who do not exist today. Think USC, Notre Dame, Oklahoma Nebraska, Penn State, Florida State, Texas, Georgia, Miami and Michigan along with one or two surprise teams that emerged in a given year.

Continue reading

Rebel Hell NO! Giants draft Ole Miss-“TE” Engram

Written by: Motown Blue

Evan Engram is the newest New York Giant.

Here are my immediate thoughts:

It happened twice before and one time during the pick. Defensive end Jonathan Allen incredulously dropped and dropped and dropped. He was the third best DL in the draft. He can play multiple positions on the line and be a huge chess piece for Spags. Think Osi, Tuck and Strahan, only younger and more athletic. That was a defining moment that put a nail in the coffin in Reese’s legacy of riding on Accorsi’s coat tails. He rode Eli, backbone of Accorsi’s base picks, 2007 picks and some luck for the 2011 championship.

Engram is a late second-round pick at best, period. A luxury pick. He will see five to seven throws per game. Can’t block. Stop with the decoy and making defenses honest BS. Can you guys remember Beckum from Wisconsin? Same deal, but Engram is more athletic. Except what round was Beckum picked? Third round. Guess where Engram should have been picked?

Linebacker Reuben Foster is a thumper and was the consensus first LB pick after the Super Bowl. Unless there is something we do not know about his off-the-field transgressions, he is the LB the Gmen have wanted to have for decades. Glenn and Pete have already laid out the scenario that made too much sense to trade up for O. J. Howard.

All of these scenarios were not break-the-bank moves in terms of picks.

Guess what the priority is tomorrow? Who is going to block for your new offensive toy?
Reese loves his toys. But what good are they if there is no foundation established?